Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Should You Add Basil Before or After Baking Your Pizza?

When it comes to making pizza, one of the great debates among enthusiasts is: Should you add basil before or after baking your pizza? It’s a small decision, but one that can completely change the way your pizza tastes, smells, and even looks. As someone who’s spent countless hours perfecting pizza recipes and techniques, let me break it down for you.

The Case for Adding Basil Before Baking

Adding basil before baking allows it to cook alongside the other ingredients, releasing its oils and infusing the pizza with a more mellow, earthy flavor. This approach is perfect if you love the way basil integrates into the sauce and cheese as it wilts in the heat.

However, keep in mind that basil added before baking can lose its vibrant green color and turn dark, almost black, during the process. While the flavor might still be there, the visual appeal might take a hit. If you’re going for that classic Neapolitan-style pizza where everything melds together, pre-bake basil could be your best bet.

The Case for Adding Basil After Baking

On the flip side, adding fresh basil after your pizza comes out of the oven keeps its bright, peppery flavor and that iconic green pop of color. There’s something undeniably fresh about biting into a slice with just-picked basil leaves.

This method works especially well for pizzas that are light on sauce or cheese, like a Margherita or a simple white pizza. The fresh basil provides a contrast that elevates the entire dish. Pro tip: If you’re adding basil post-bake, drizzle a little olive oil over it to enhance the flavor even more.

So, Which is Better?

The truth is, it depends on the pizza you’re making and your personal preference. If you want the basil to blend seamlessly into the pizza, go for pre-bake. If you want a fresh, bold finish, add it after baking.

For me, it’s about balance. On most pizzas, I’ll add a bit of basil before baking for that subtle, infused flavor, and then toss a few fresh leaves on top after baking for the visual appeal and fresh taste. It’s the best of both worlds.

A Quick Tip for the Perfect Basil

If you’re worried about basil burning or losing its flavor in the oven, try tucking the leaves under a layer of cheese. This way, it stays protected and flavorful without charring. And if you’re using basil post-bake, always tear the leaves by hand instead of cutting them with a knife—this prevents bruising and keeps the oils intact.

For more insights on how to enhance your pizza-making skills, check out my favorite dough recipe or learn how I pair ingredients with the perfect bread from Serpico’s Bread Co..

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re team pre-bake or post-bake, basil is one of those ingredients that can transform a pizza from good to unforgettable. Experiment with both methods and find out what works best for you. At the end of the day, pizza-making is about having fun and making something you—and those around you—can’t wait to devour.

For more pizza-making tips and stories from the hospitality world, subscribe to my Bread for the People podcast.

External Links:

  1. Guide to Neapolitan Pizza
  2. Basil Varieties and Flavor Profiles

Internal Backlinks:

  1. Pizza Dough Recipe
  2. Serpico’s Bread Co.
  3. Bread for the People Podcast

 

CONSUME
Newsletter

Name
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

JIM SERPICO

© Jim Serpico 2025. All rights reserved. Website Designed by Reclaim Digital

Contact

Contact

Name(Required)
Newsletter
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.