The Moment It Begins

There’s a moment in business that feels like clarity.

A product takes off. A concept breaks through. A line forms out the door.
And suddenly, the path forward looks obvious.

Do that.

Not because you were told to.
Because it’s working.

That’s the moment External Group Think begins.

A Different Kind of Pressure

We talk a lot about groupthink inside organizations—teams aligning, ideas getting softened, dissent fading.

But there’s another force that doesn’t come from a boss or a meeting.

It comes from the market itself.

External Group Think is what happens when we stop asking, What am I great at?
…and start asking, What seems to be working right now?

It feels like awareness.

It’s still conformity.

We’ve Seen This Before

Frozen yogurt shops. Cupcakes. Donuts. Açaí bowls.

One idea breaks through—and suddenly it’s everywhere.

For a moment, it looks like the future.

Then it thins out.

Not because the idea was bad.
Because too many people built the same version of it at the same time.

When an Idea Becomes a Category

We’ve seen it in television too.

One show hits—and suddenly there’s a wave behind it.

In reality TV, it’s obvious.

Attractive people living together. Relationships forming. Cameras always on.

Different names. Different locations. Same engine.

I spent years watching this happen.

An idea works—and almost overnight, it becomes a category.

And once that happens, the question shifts.

From “Is this original?”
to “Is this close enough to what works?”

The Algorithm Effect

And it’s not just business or television.

Scroll through Instagram.

At first it feels creative.

Then you start to notice the sameness—
the same hooks, the same pacing, the same voice.

Not because people lack ideas.

Because they’re paying attention.

Because it works.

The Pull to Conform

I’ve felt it myself.

I’ll see something working—how someone frames a video, how they open—and I feel the pull to do it that way.

Sometimes I do.

Not because it’s me.
Because I know it works.

And in that moment, I’m not building from instinct.

I’m building from evidence.

Replication Disguised as Tradition

I see it in my own industry.

Walk into ten pizzerias, you’ll see ten versions of the same menu.

It looks like tradition.

But most of it is replication.

At some point, what worked stopped being a choice—and became a template.

How It Actually Works

External Group Think doesn’t shout.

It whispers:

This is what sells.
This is what people want.

And slowly, you stop building from identity…
and start building from proof.

Why It’s So Hard to Resist

To be fair, there’s a reason this happens.

Familiarity works.
Customers expect certain things.

And imitation does pay—at least for a while.

That’s what makes it dangerous.

The Hidden Risk

Because the safest move eventually becomes the riskiest one.

You don’t stand out.

You blend in.

And blending in might get you open…

but it won’t make you matter.

The Real Failure

Most businesses don’t fail because they were too different.

They fail because they were never different enough to be chosen.

The Only Question That Matters

The question isn’t whether you’re influenced.

You are.

The question is whether you ever stop long enough to ask:

What would this look like if it actually came from me?

The Final Line

Because if your idea only works when everyone else is doing it…

it was never really yours.

If this resonated with you, I publish essays like this every Monday morning. If you’d like them in your inbox you can sign up here.